|
Papers: [alphabetical order - P to Z]
Michelle
Parslow
University of Exeter
mlp203@exeter.ac.uk
Posthuman Biorage: Articulating Bodies in real, virtual
and fictive utopian spaces
Utopian and science fiction boasts a long history in the exploration
of the mind/body dialectic. This engagement has become only more
vital as technologies involving the pursuit of the utopian body
have evolved. Since the 1970s especially, the increased availability
of cosmetic surgery and sex-reassignment surgery has enabled the
production of one's ideal physical body. If transformative
surgery gave us the ability to reconstruct the material life of
the body beyond the human – or posthuman; virtual life granted
us opportunities for segregating our sense of selves from our bodies
– for being transhuman. The latter is perhaps best observed
when we consider the phenomenal impact of the online utopian community,
especially in the form of Internet chat rooms and virtual world
websites, such as the recently-reviewed 'Second Life'
project. To a certain extent, these utopian spaces facilitate a
self-defining disengagement from our organic, material bodies. This
may be one reason why what it means to be human within a utopian
space seems to have been largely expressed as either an entirely
material or an entirely subjective praxis. Reading both fictional,
real-life and virtual life 'utopian' spaces within Pat
Cadigan's Dervish is Digital (2000) and the American-based
virtual world website 'Second Life,' I interrogate the
dualistic nature of conceptualising (post)humanity within utopia.
Synthesising Judith Butler's concept of 'illegible rage'
and recent readings of Foucauldian 'biopower,' I argue
that the body in utopian space is neither an exclusively 'material'
– nor exclusively 'virtual' – concept. Instead,
it is one which is situated within a praxis which I term 'biorage.'
Keywords: biorage, trans, cyberfeminism
Banu Pekol
Istanbul Technical University, Institute of Science and Technology,
PhD Candidate in Architectural History
bpekol@gmail.com
A Strategy of Denial or a Vehicle for Rebirth: The Architecture
of the Turkish Revolution
There exist two opinions on the role of architecture, or rather,
the means for which it was employed during the early years of the
Turkish Republic. The concept of rural development is seen and interpreted
through these two viewpoints to support the two distinct arguments.
One claim is that the dignitaries of the Early Republic of Turkey
wanted never to cross paths with the villagers -who formed the majority
of the public- but on the other hand over-glorified them in their
campaigns. They denied to admit the villagers into their mindframe,
and to rid themselves of shame, designed ideal villages for them,
which they never implemented. The other viewpoint believes that
those in charge during this period candidly worked for ideals which
foreign experts labelled as 'dreams' and that these
were comprehensive projects aiming at fulfilling agricultural, economic,
social, cultural and environmental needs. These projects, headed
by Ataturk, were all part of a grand scheme for the good of the
public, awakening from under the oppression of the Ottoman Empire.
The 'Ideal Republic Village', a pilot project designed
in 1932 for the First Industrial Plan, forms the focal point of
the paper. It is considered a utopian vision by many, but for different
reasons. This project will be presented in the light of other architectural
undertakings of the age which employed similar 'utopian'
ideals. Examples to be mentioned will include the Village-City,
the most comprehensive rural development project and government
buildings intended to shape the decisions of those who worked within
them.
Keywords: ideal cities, Turkish Republic, utopia and architecture
Marilyn Pemberton
University of Warwick
m.a.pemberton@warwick.ac.uk
Glimpses of Utopia in Victorian Fairylands
The second half of the nineteenth century was the 'Golden
Age' of children's literature and the fairy tale had
become 'acceptable' reading. Both utopian literature
and fairy tales critique contemporary society and the concerns prevalent
during this period were as diverse as the effects of mass-production
and materialism on society, the existence of a life after death,
the role of women and the institution of marriage. In this paper
I will argue that such writers as George MacDonald, Mary de Morgan,
Mary Louisa Molesworth, Oscar Wilde and others chose specifically
to write in the fairy tale genre so as to take full advantage of
its inherent utopian function, in order to address these concerns
and to reveal glimpses of their own yearnings for an improved society.
I will show also that there is a distinct similarity in literary
conventions between utopian texts and the 'magical'
Victorian fairy tales, emphasising further their common purpose.
In the 'magical' fairy tale a visitor from the 'real'
world enters fairyland through an enchanted boundary, the rules
of this land are different and must be learned, usually with the
help of a guide, and when the visitor returns home having learned
an invaluable lesson he will, like his utopian counterpart, consequently
be an improved and improving person. In this paper, having explained
further the utopian function of the Victorian fairy tale, I will
explore one of the fairy tales by Mary de Morgan, who was a friend
of William Morris and was greatly influenced by his utopianism.
Keywords: Victorian, Fairy tales
Saskia Poldervaart
University of Amsterdam
s.w.poldervaart@uva.nl
How utopianism disappeared from Dutch socialist feminism
(1970-1989)
Social movements always have used three different strategies: the
utopian Do-it-Yourself, the revolutionary and the negotiating strategy.
In my paper I will analyse these different strategies and shortly
show how the 'Dolle Mina's' struggled with a choice
between the utopian and the revolutionary strategy. Most attention
will be given to the three socialist feminist journals (Newsletter
of the Feminist Socialist Platform; Katijf and Socialist Feminist
Texts). I will analyse the discussions in these journals and elaborate
how the attitude of 'we feminists want to show that life can
be different' slowly shifted into a strive for power and individual
career making by accepting the emancipation policy of the government.
More and more attention has been given to professionalizing, usefulness
of rights and getting subsidies. Socialist feminists who pleaded
to use the (utopian) strategy of self organisation and autonomy
(with their ideas of rejecting hierarchy, giving alternatives for
daily life, making your own politics and language), as well as the
negotiating strategy at the same time, have not realized that doing
both with the same group is almost impossible. For the negotiating
strategy means that you have to adjust your language, to appoint
representatives and to accept that the government decides with whom
you have to work together. My paper will show which arguments these
feminists have used to change the 'personal is political'
strategy into one directed to the government and how by this the
utopian momentum disappeared from the movement.
Keywords: strategies, politics of utopia, feminism
Miguel
Ramalhete
University of Porto
migramalhete@hotmail.com
The city and the plan: Schuiten and Peeters' graphic
meta-utopias
In 1983, François Schuiten and Benoît Peeters published
a comic book story called The Walls of Samaris in the magazine A
Suivre, a story which would afterwards be published in book format,
marking the starting-point of a collaboration which has since then
given us several other albums and related objects, all of them concerning
the complex universe of the so-called Obscure Cities.
In this study I intend to go through this series, so as to try to
determine and develop its already well-known connections to Utopian
Literature. To do so, I will consider most of its albums and connected
objects and will focus my attention on their spatial, textual and
generic construction. I will first explore the spatial construction
of the series, through the use of Spatiality Studies theory, which
will already have generic consequences. These consequences will
in turn be revised in the part about the intricately self-referential
textual construction of the albums. The last part of my essay will
then consider several possibilities of classifying this universe
within Utopian Literature and will attempt to show why only the
category of meta-utopia is capable of including and describing all
these cities as a whole.
Keywords: 'graphic novel', spatiality, meta-utopia
Iolanda Ramos
Universidade Nova de Lisboa, Portugal
iolanda.ramos@fcsh.unl.pt
Utopia Meets Utility – Victorian Museology and
Political Discourse
The traditional model of a museum as both storehouse and bastion
of truth is usually assigned to the Victorian period, a time that
also witnessed the emergence of the modern museum strategies of
public accessibility, advancement of learning, and systematic arrangement
of objects. This paper begins by discussing the complexity underlying
the nature and purpose of museums as historical and cultural manifestations.
It asserts that a museum is a system of representation and thus
it does not deal solely with objects but with ideas. Specific notions
of what a museum should be, as a shared public space, are combined
with the broad context of town planning, community and citizenship.
Lastly, the essay argues that as a way of achieving public pleasure,
civic education and communal responsibility, Victorian museology
puts forward political discourses of utility and utopia.
Keywords: Politics of Utopia, Victorian museology, community
Paul Ramsay
Chameleon
Lectra
University of Plymouth
p1ramsay@plymouth.ac.uk
Parallel Music – Towards a Utopian Compositional
Form
The development and appreciation of musical forms has been forever
changed by the advent of sound representational technologies. Whereas
the writing of music allowed for the development of complex melodic
and harmonic structures (far beyond what would have been possible
within a purely 'oral' culture), the gramophone record
and its successive technologies foregrounded elements such as timbre,
the location of sound (reverberation, spatial placement etc.) and
the break with causality as places of innovation. They have also
made complex notions of 'presence', 'musical time'
and 'originality'.
The computer has further enriched this situation by offering possibilities
beyond the predictable, linear unfolding of composed music. Drawing
upon the ideas of composers such as John Cage and Pierre Schaeffer
and cultural commentators such as Walter Ong and J.D. Bolter, this
paper, given in the form of a presentation with short musical examples,
will discuss the above and outline, in response, an indeterminate,
computer-based compositional method entitled 'Parallel Music',
under development since 1996.
Keywords: Composition, Parallel Music, Indeterminacy, Consemble
Jose Reis
jmlreis@sapo.pt
Millenarian Utopia: António Vieira and the Puritan
'Fifth Monarchy Men'
The prophetic and messianic quality of the theocratic thought of
the Portuguese Jesuit António Vieira, shaped by the idea
of the universal Christian redemption of humanity, is not a curious,
exclusive epiphenomenon of seventeenth-century Portuguese literary
culture. With our paper, we will attempt to put forward the thesis
that the millenarianist, utopian component of the Portuguese Jesuit's
work is indissociable from one the most dynamic forms of the utopian
thought - as it was historically, culturally and literally manifest
in the western culture - i.e., the idealistic form that plans the
construction of a better place in a final time and perfect future.
To do this, we shall analyse and demonstrate, based on significant
texts of Vieira: (i) the articulation between prophecy and utopia
in his messianic vision of the world, explaining how the superficial
structure of the prophetic-millenarianist, theocratic and 'lusocentric'
discourse of Vieira is related to the profound structure of ontological
hope in a universal 'metanoia' (the essential hope of
all utopianism, as Ernst Bloch demonstrated); (ii) the transnational
quality of the origins
of this discourse, explaining how the biblical form of Vieira millenarianism,
crystallised in the idea of the fifth empire, inspired treatises
of a millenarianist sect called the 'Fifth Monarchy Men'
that in seventeenth century England were structurally similar to
the pattern of the Portuguese.
Beate Rodewald
Palm Beach Atlantic University
Beate_Rodewald@pba.edu
Artful Productions and Revealing Re-cognitions in The
Tempest and The Forbidden Planet
Current scholarship on literature takes post-colonial insights concerning
representations of other cultures in literature of the Exploration
Age for granted; however, some 'canonical' works have
been largely unexplored for their utopian dimensions. While Montaigne's
'Of Cannibals' is always cited as one possible inspiration
for Shakespeare's Tempest and lots of scholarship exists on
connections between Renaissance literature and Exploration voyages,
little has been said about the play's thorough exposition
of issues concerning mimesis and alterity that go beyond the mere
'otherness' represented by Caliban, the native of the
island. The transformations all the characters undergo can be analyzed
in terms of contemporary European/New-World relations at the same
time that they are meta-theatrical manifestations of the power of
art to evoke change. The play presents a utopian alternative world
where the artist /magician orchestrates encounters that reveal the
true natures of all involved. A thorough reading of the play's
meta-theatrical scenes provides grounds for theoretical issues concerning
the function of aesthetics and the productive and generative role
of art. The 1956 'adaptation' of the play in the utopian
mode favored in the 20th century, science-fiction, reveals that
century's utopian dimension of the popular imagination. In
addition to the meta-theatrical discussion, the play and the adaptation
will be analyzed for the relation between their respective utopian
alternate world and their treatment of time or history.
Keywords: literature, art, theory
Luis
Gómez Romero
Universidad Carlos III de Madrid
Luigi_in_spain@yahoo.es
Lasciate ogne speranza: Harry Potter and the depths
of penitentiary exclusion
As a pragmatist, Richard Rorty asserts that the construction of
a culture of human rights owes more to the reading of sad and sentimental
histories than to the increase of moral knowledge. Although this
point of view is extremely disputable, it also sustains a very provocative
epistemological proposal: the ethical values that support human
rights can become enriched by literature. The dystopian genre is
specially fitted for this sort of moral deliberation. My claim is
that Azkaban's prison, as it is depicted in J. K. Rowling's
Potter series, is a dystopian icon that may clarify us the human
rights principle that Francesco Carrara stated in the following
way: 'the defence of rights is not complete if it is not effective
for all, that is, for those which have broken the Law as for those
that have not transgressed it yet'.
Keywords: Dystopia, Prison, Human Rights
Elizabeth Russell
Universitat Rovira i Virgili, Tarragona
liz.russell@urv.cat
The Body as Dystopia: Spectacle and Surveillance in
Deham
Manjula Padmanaban's play Harvest (1997) and Govind Nihalini's film
version of the same, Deham (2002, The Body), are dystopian works
which discuss the selling of body organs by poverty-stricken third-world
donors to rich first-world buyers who are trying to lengthen their
lives. This paper will look at the processes of being and becoming;
the mapping of dis/embodied space, and the body as a site invested
by gender and colonial power relations. The play and film can be
read in many ways, most obviously the exploitation of the third
world to benefit the first but there are also alternative readings
which point to contemporary anxieties such as global surveillance,
the policing of boundaries, and the ethical problems involved in
the emergence of new human identities which no longer see the self
as one body, oneself, but a Frankensteinian agglomeration of different
bodies in one self.
Keywords: dystopia, Deham, dis/embodied space
Lyman Tower Sargent
University of Missouri-St. Louis
University of Oxford
lyman.sargent@umsl.edu
Utopia and/in Everyday Life: Reflections on the Relationship
Between Utopianism and Communitarianism
In this paper I look at utopianism as the transformation of the
everyday, a way of looking at the topic that sees change in the
everyday as potentially the area of most importance. And what better
place to look at such a topic than intentional communities, in which
sharing the changes with others may make the transformation easier.
I am most concerned with the utopias of the communities, what they
hope/d to achieve rather than what they achieved. But what has been
actually achieved will also play a role. The Shakers, Oneida, Kerista,
Centrepoint and others changed sexual behavior radically. Many communities
changed how people ate, and the vegetarian communities changed what
people ate. Many communities changed how work was organized, and
particularly broke down gender distinctions in how work was allocated.
Others worked with some success at breaking down the distinction
between mental and physical labor (See Kesten for a study of everyday
life in nineteenth century U.S. communities). All this is familiar
to any student of intentional communities, but I shall argue that
its implications for the connection between utopianism and communitarianism
have been ignored. In this paper, I try to draw out those implications
and argue that the intentional community movement should be seen
as truly revolutionary.
Dr. Peter Scheers
University of Leuven, Belgium
peter.scheers@hiw.kuleuven.be
Possibilism and the complexity of perfection
My paper will discuss the central role of a complex perfective philosophy
of appraisal in the construction of an adequate possibilism (including,
perhaps, utopianism as the most eminent form of possibilism). My
analysis in part refers back to an earlier inquiry of mine (Towards
a Complex Perfectionism, Peeters Publishers, 2005), but now with
a special focus on the issue of possibilism. Lack of concern for
a.) the existing plurality of, and tensions between, valuable and
culturally influential standards of perfection (such as purity,
completeness, richness, depth, efficiency, scope, appropriateness,
etc.) and/or b.) the plurality of gradational levels (in the context
of an always relative fulfilment of perfective standards) and/or
c.) the ways in which our reflective and emotional consideration
of future possibilities is itself to be appreciated in terms of
better and worse, is bound to lead to the articulation of inadequate
and even dangerous versions of possibilism such as technological
and economic progressivism (which today have even brought us to
a time of radical catastrophism). A renewed utopian consciousness
should include the ideal of a refined and complex appraisive self,
who would hopefully find his or her place in the world of politics
and business.
Lars Schmeink, M.A.
University of Hamburg
lars@wortraub.com
Fears of Globalization – Anti-Corporate Visions
in Recent Utopian Texts
Ever since Thomas More published his 'Utopia', literature
has been a mirror of society's vision of a possible future. The
presentation of 'no place' has since been a reflection
of contemporary dreams, wishes and desires but also of fears and
nightmares. It is the vision of how we would like the future to
be, but also the critique of how it should better not become. In
recent visual and literary production the future possible world
has become the image of an inhumane and technologized existence
in which corporate enterprises have taken over and established a
life of their own. We are not afraid of totalitarian governments
anymore but rather fear being ground in the machinery of corporate
profit making. Lives are but a mere commodity to be used in the
fabrication of ever more productive corporations. Films like 'Resident
Evil', 'Renaissance: Paris 2054' or 'The
Island' as well as books like Margaret Atwood's 'Oryx
& Crake', Max Barry's 'Jennifer Government',
William Gibson's 'Pattern Recognition' show the
deep seated fear that uncontrolled scientific progress and economical
avarice will leave human society victimized by its own creations.
The paper shows how recent utopian texts (from novels to films and
computer games) have replaced the totalitarian nation state with
the globalized corporation as the root of a dystopian vision.
Keywords: Anti-Corporate Sentiment, Dystopia, Globalization
Ulrich Muller-Scholl
University of Addis Ababa
Um-s@gmx.net
Globalization as a Chance for 'Concrete Utopias'
Once u-topias, as ideas of a better world, were characterized by
the fact that they had 'no place'. Later on, they were
replaced by representations of progress as a 'philosophico-historical'
idea. Taking most different shapes but following its own fixed laws,
it was e.g. conceived in the 19th century as a cyclic movement that
would end in a full circle on a new level: e.g. as 'consciousness
of freedom' (Hegel) or 'realm of freedom' (Marx).
Only in the 20th century this imagination was replaced by a linear
idea of progress - as a never ending process.
Such progress by most German philosophers was considered as a curse
(Heidegger and his school). But at the same time 'Utopia'
was rediscovered as 'concrete utopia' - progress had to
be critically accompanied by ideas for a qualitative catharsis (cf.
Allianztechnik, Ernst Bloch): This shift was the precursor of a
turning point we are still witnessing.
At the end of the 1960th a new attitude towards progress led to
the claim of 'sustainable development', a concept that
evaluates the consequences of progress in advance and thus stresses
the need for an idea of a desired future. This turn to such anticipation
of the future was ironically pushed by globalization. As paradigms
of progress from the developed world, when adopted by other cultures,
often produce shortcomings and deception, encompassing concepts
including cultural, environmental, ethnical aspects etc. are needed.
'Concrete utopia' might be one of the forms to realize
such thinking.
Keywords: Progress, Globalization, Concrete Utopia
Ayse Senturer
Istanbul Technical University
Senturer@itu.edu
FINDING THE LOST (ARCHITECTU-REAL) UTOPIAS: New Proposals
for City Life
Could reality, especially the (dark) reality of city life, bring
the lost architectural utopias back together with the individual
lost in time, space and life? This paper will deal with this question.
Within this mind-set, it will underline the importance of concentrating
on complexities, dark-sides, in-visible parts of city life, which
rise generally at the borderlines of the city. However, it will
especially underline the importance of receiving and processing
that kind of knowledge of the (dark) city life, which is very much
related as to how we perceive and conceive the world in today's
changing conditions, especially at the edge, in borderline situations.
Those facts, at the same time, represent the dynamics of today's
life and they are related to transitive and intransitive qualities
of cities, which we can be summarized them as presentation, movement/flow,
communication, transportation, and sharing/exchange capacities of
the city; briefly as the passage and interaction capacities in between
space-time-life through architecture! Afterward, 'critical-cultural
and cinematographic 'city' conceptions' will be
introduced as a very essential and creative architectural design
approach (tools and techniques) to acquire, to simulate, and to
process that kind of knowledge, which brings the possibility of
converting the existing relationships into new forms of space-time-life
interactions, and will in turn open up new possibilities for the
city life. This approach is also introduced as a passage from reality
to imaginary, fantasia or utopia, which will come back to the reality
and hopefully help to transform a desperate individual into a more
capable one. Finally, the design practices of that approach realized
at the Architectural Design Studious at ITU in Istanbul and RMIT
in Melbourne by the author and her students will be brought in as
'new proposals for city life' including remarks that
the Design Studio is the real practicing area of utopian ideas.
Akin Sevinç
akinsevinc@hotmail.com
Signals from Different Worlds: Sources of Inspiration
for Utopian Architecture
'Another world is possible': A signal from the 20th
century
The quintessence of a utopia is to present a new and ideal social
model. Doing this means designing new and ideal living spaces at
the same time. Therefore, utopias may be treated as sketches for
architectural projects. In a professional sense, the appearance
of imaginary architectural projects (those designed by architects
or city planners) coincides with the early 20th century. Manifested
through these projects and now almost 100 years old, utopian architecture's
main aim is to design new and ideal living spaces. During this process,
a new and ideal social model is also designed. Such architectural
projects may thus be seen as sketches for utopias. This study aims
to investigate the sources of inspiration for utopian architecture
by reviewing imaginary projects. Some of the signals that express
these projects have been eloquently articulated by their designers:
Circus, labyrinth, game, genetic code, space trip, war fatigue,
anarchy, spider, parasite, tree, Rosa Luxemburg, hovercraft, transatlantic,
helicopter, oil refinery, etc. Other signals are less explicit:
DNA spiral, human body, insect, internet heart, funfair, etc. Through
such imaginary projects did utopian architecture assume the small
but important place it occupies in the history of architecture.
Its heyday in the 1960s was a time rightly encompassed by the slogan
'Another world is possible'. It underwent change, and
meanwhile changed the utopian tradition, of which it is a part.
The creative spirit that gave birth to 'other' imaginary
worlds – and drew its power from the very fact that they were
not real – has lived on. It became a source of inspiration
for projects 'like no other', and this trend seems likely
to continue into the future.
Keywords: Utopian architecture, source of inspiration, imaginary
projects
Dr. Peter Seyferth
Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München
peter.seyferth@gsi.uni-muenchen.de
From The Dispossessed to Always Coming Home: making
utopia really anarchistic
Ursula K. Le Guin's first utopia, 'The Dispossessed' (1974),
is widely recognised as one of the most convincing critical or open-ended
utopias. But Le Guin has written more that is relevant for the utopian
discourse, especially an essay that criticises historical utopias
in general and proposes standards for a new kind of utopia: A Non-Euclidean
View of California as a Cold Place to Be (1982); and she wrote a
second, also anarchist utopia: 'Always Coming Home' (1985). In my
paper, I will depict her criticism on utopias and compare the two
utopias within this context. In her essay Le Guin addresses several
problems of previous utopias (including 'The Dispossessed') and
looks for solutions in Taoism and anthropological theories (especially
from Claude Lévi-Strauss and Victor Turner), which leads
her to propose new standards concerning content and literary form
of utopia. Against the future-orientation of present societies and
utopias she promotes a separation of technological progress from
society, allowing society an organism-like stability that is neither
dogmatic nor static. She pleads for 'a society predominantly
concerned with preserving its existence; a society with a modest
standard of living, conservative of natural resources, with a low
constant fertility rate and a political life based upon consent;
a society that has made a successful adaptation to its environment
and has learned to live without destroying itself or the people
next door.' Additionally to this content, a new kind of utopia
needs a literary form that encourages the reader's imagination
to take part in the construction of utopia—this makes utopia
really open-ended and anarchistic on a higher level. I will show
in detail that her second utopia meets these standards whereas 'The
Dispossessed' fails, making 'Always Coming Home' Le Guin's
most hopeful, anarchist, and relevant book that deserves further
attention.
Keywords: Le Guin, anarchism, literary utopias
Jorge Bastos da Silva
Universidade do Porto, Portugal
jmsilva@letras.up.pt
Political Conservatism and Pastoral Utopianism: The
Case of Viscount Bolingbroke
Henry St. John, Viscount Bolingbroke, was a member of the last Tory
cabinet under Queen Anne and in that capacity one of the English
negotiators of the Peace of Utrecht of 1713. After the Hanoverian
Succession, however, fearing imprisonment and possibly murder, he
fled to France. When he returned to England in 1723 he became a
prominent figure in the so-called 'Patriot' opposition
to Walpole. Having been deprived of the right to sit in the House
of Lords, Bolingbroke devoted himself not so much to active party
or power politics as to a refashioning of conservative ideology
which is simultaneously regressive and forward-looking. This he
did along three main lines, which I will venture to call the theoretical,
the poetic and the dramatic. (1) He formulated a moral ideal of
government, linking the Augustan imperative of politeness with the
core republican values of public spirit in a benevolent conception
of rule. (2) Through a subtle engagement with Virgil's Georgics
and The Aeneid, he envisioned both peace and georgic plenty and
a golden age of empire for Great Britain with implicit historical
sanction given by the Roman precedent. (3) In accordance with his
paternalistic ideal of social relations, he posed as a gentleman-farmer
surrounded by a select homosocial circle of friends, assuming a
stance which was supposedly reminiscent of the gentry of bygone
days. He consequently presented Dawley Farm as a sort of heterotopia,
as it were outside the world of corruption.
Keywords: Pastoral, Patriotism, Republicanism
Alexandra Sippel
University of Paris-Sorbonne.
Alexandra.sippel@wanadoo.fr
Artists and artistic atmosphere in modern British Utopias
Utopian writers of the 18th and early 19th centuries were very much
influenced by the humanist trend that was the hallmark of More's
original text. Later texts were still strongly marked by Ancient
philosophers and beauty is therefore central in all eutopias. Beauty,
according to platonist ideas, was the outer sign of goodness and
truth – which means that a happy society was to be beautifully
organised. My paper will have to do with the artistic atmosphere
that surrounds utopias. I will focus on several texts to show what
side utopists took in the famous quarrel of the Ancient and the
Modern – Antiquity often remained the arch-artistic model,
especially in the ideal cooperative community of Loch Lomond in
Morgan's Revolt of the Bees, but also in Sarah Scott's
Millenium Hall. The second question I shall raise is that of the
place of artists. Though beauty is everywhere in eutopias (and is
sometimes deceitful in dystopias), artists are strangely excluded,
or are not recognised as useful members of the city. Artistic talent
seems to be universally distributed among utopians, and this shall
lead me to investigate the regard cast on artists in the novels
I mentioned and others in order to better understand why they were
not as glorified in ideal societies as they were in Europe at the
same period. This question seems particuliarly relevant with regard
to English utopias, at a time when Joshua Reynolds and the Royal
Academy gained fame and consecrated British art.
Keywords: Aesthetics, Influence of Antiquity, Artists'
social standard
Dan Smith
University of the Arts London
wunderkammer@btinternet.com
The House of Dreams: Program and Impulse within the
work of Ilya and Emilia Kabakov
This paper will address the presence of both forms of utopian project
and impulse within the work of artists Ilya and Emilia Kabakov,
focusing on their installation The House of Dreams (2005). At its
spatial centre is a radial arrangement of oversize pedestals, complete
with steps, at the top of which is situated a divan to rest or sleep
upon. Inside each large pedestal is a small chamber, again furnished
for institutionalised rest. The adjoining rooms have become hallucinatory
adaptations of a hospital ward. The form is derived from a scheme
within the history of Soviet utopias devised by architect Konstantin
Melnikov. After identifying the problem of fatigue as a hindrance
to the growth and development of the Stalinist collective, he proposed
a Laboratory of Sleep (1929), which would allow up to 4,000 workers
to rest in order to restore them to their full productive potential.
The plan of a central rotunda flanked by two wings is mirrored in
the creation of the Kabakovs' installation, as is its promise
of a restorative slumber. However, in its reconstruction, the Laboratory
is detached from its pragmatic attempts to improve efficiency and
functional productivity, as well as the operation of totalitarianism.
What is on offer here, perhaps, is a chance to dream. Yet the dream
in itself is not the object of interest here. It is that this is
a state from which one will awaken that is more significant.
Keywords: Contemporary Art Soviet Union Material Culture
Phil Smith
University of Plymouth and Dartington College of Arts
perform.smith@ukgateway.net
Dispersing the boundaries of utopia – a mobile
paper
I would like to propose a mobile paper – in which the 20 minute
journey around sites immediately adjacent to the conference would
be integral. It will argue the continuing efficacy of the idea of
utopia by re-thinking it away from a bounded 'ideal' geography and
towards a practical mobility informed by a theory of space as trajectories
and the tactics of Guy Debord. Where utopian thinking has implied
a violent 'leap' from ideal to material, the paper proposes
to take seriously utopia's placelessness and the crucial function
of its image: the representation of what does not exist ('no-place').
Rather than Baudrillard's simulacrum, it will emphasise the
conservative tendency of this image to remain an image; its recalcitrance
in a spectacular economy of images become efficacious and resistant.
The paper suggests adopting the International Lettristes'
tactic of ambulatory research - the dérive – as a model
of a sociable, mobile utopia, with its aspiration to 'no-place',
set in motion with, but displaced from the economy of images and
refusing an exchange with them. Rather than a making of value, the
dérive is a making of situations utilising void (Careri)
or superfluous (Neilsen) places and a revival of previous utopian
projects – like Wells' World Brain – but as the
trajectories of cells rather than the impositions of technocrats
or central committees.
Keywords: mobile resistant cells
John Style
Universitat Rovira I Virgili, Tarragona, Spain
john.style@urv.cat
The band which grooves, the team which scores: seeking
apt metaphors for a utopian consciousness.
In this paper, I will consider the idea of utopian consciousness
– whether there is such a thing, and how it could best be
described. Is it individual or collective? Metaphors of collective
cooperative practices, such as sports teams, or improvising jazz
bands, as proposed by Ruth Levitas, have been suggested as the most
apt description of a utopian consciousness. Indeed, some theorists,
such as Davis, have claimed that the utopian project must be expressed
collectively to be genuinely utopian. Basing myself on the work
of the contemporary 'anti-guru' Tony Parsons, my contention
is that a veritable utopian consciousness only comes into being
at a point when a sense of both the individual and the collective
disappear. Desire - which engenders any utopian project - is a projection
of the Self, into the space of the Other. I will suggest that all
discussion of utopian borders, political or social projections into
the future, are mere metaphors for the illusory Self trying to convince
itself and others of its own existence in space and time. Utopian
projects and probably even utopian studies have a vested interest
in remaining unachieved and unachievable, as a means by which the
Self maintains the illusion of its own existence.
Keywords: utopia, consciousness, metaphor
Trude Diesen Sundberg
University of Oslo
Trude_diesen@yahoo.co.uk
The Challenges for a global Utopia: A review of the
World Social Forum's first years
In opposition to the politics of emergencies dominating our world
today, seen for example by the constant focus on threats, the World
Social Forum (WSF) and the new social movements launched their first
forum in 2001 claiming 'Another World is Possible'.
This paper will focus on this yearly forum, which may be seen as
an attempt to move away from traditional political thinking. The
first meeting was organised in Porto Alegre in Brazil, with a wide
variety of organisations and individuals' participating, in
what was established as an alternative to the World Economic Forum's
yearly meetings in Davos. The forum seeks to transgress from the
traditional state based way of thinking through slogans like 'think
global act local', and a network based organisational system.
This paper aims to review the existence and development of possible
utopias and/or utopianism within the WSF by analysing final papers
and decisions, news coverage and articles written by participants.
If there was, and still is a utopian impulse; has the diversity
of the movements come through in the ideas, and has it caused any
problems? Which challenges, if any, have possible utopias met? These
are just some of the questions I seek to answer through the paper
by using both the traditional concept of Utopia, and newer theories
influenced by feminism and the green movement using a wider definition.
Keywords: Challenges, World Social Forum, globalisation
Kathryn Tomasek
Wheaton College, Norton, Massachusetts, USA
ktomasek@wheatonma.edu
Transatlantic Travel in U.S. Fourierism
Historians have long recognized the significance of the grand tour
undertaken by New Yorker Albert Brisbane in the 1820s and 1830s
for the development of a U.S. movement based on the thought of Charles
Fourier. A later European tour by Marcus and Rebecca Spring, New
York Fourierists who were patrons of the North American Phalanx
and the Raritan Bay Union, suggests the ongoing significance of
transatlantic travel and consequent networks of friendship, especially
for women. Transcendentalist Margaret Fuller travelled with Marcus
and Rebecca Spring in the 1840s, and the Springs were important
contacts for Swedish feminist Fredrika Bremer when she visited the
United States in the 1850s, making the North American Phalanx one
of her numerous stops on her own tour.
Using Fuller's reports in the New York Tribune and Bremer's
Homes of the New World, this paper explores parallels between Brisbane's
European idylls and the European and American tours of Fuller and
Bremer. The paper illustrates the transatlantic reach of the networks
that were central to the experiences of Fourierist women in the
United States in the 1840s and 1850s.
Darren Webb
University of Sheffield
d.webb@sheffield.ac.uk
Anti-Utopian Hope
Hope is a key theme within utopian studies. This paper is drawn
from a wider research project which explores the different modes
in which human hope can be experienced and the ways in which these
articulate with the utopian impulse. Whilst hope can be experienced
in critical and transformative modes, which both feed off and inspire
utopian discourse and praxis, there are also non-utopian and anti-utopian
modes of hoping. The paper focuses on the latter, primarily because
the notion that hope can possesses an anti-utopian functionality
is generally overlooked, or is at least downplayed, within utopian
studies. Looking in particular at the work of Gabriel Marcel, the
paper explores human hope as an experience which transcends desire
and the imagination and rejects all modes of utopia as a species
of presumptuous impatience.
Keywords: Hope, Patience, Marcel
Toby Widdicombe
UAA, Anchorage, AK 99508, USA
afrtw@uaa.alaska.edu
Wordsworth, the River Duddon sonnets, and the Idea of
Community
Wordsworth's peripheral role in Coleridge's and Southey's
utopian proposals (such as Pantisocracy) is well known. What has
been much less examined in the utopian vein is how the River Duddon
sonnet collection* (published in April 1820)—accompanied as
it was by a memorial essay to the 'Wonderful Walker'
and a revised version of the Guide to the District of the Lakes—constitutes
the description of a viable community. More generally such apparent
viability is buttressed by Wordsworth's status as the head
of the 'Lakers' (or the school of Lake poets) and of
Rydal Mount as the focal point for a set of views that puts forward
a utopian definition of hope, ideology, and the betterment of society.
* The full title of the sonnet collection—The
River Duddon, A Series of Sonnets: Vaudracour and Julia: and Other
Poems. To Which Is Annexed a Topographical Description of the Country
of the Lakes, in the North of England.
Keywords: Wordsworth, Lake poets, River Duddon sonnets
Anna Vaninskaya
Kings College, University of Cambridge
av323@cam.ac.uk
The Coast of Utopia: Stoppard, Herzen, and The Strange
Death of the Liberal Intelligentsia
Tom Stoppard's three-part play The Coast of Utopia (2002)
is one of the most interesting and high-profile dramatic treatments
of utopianism in recent years, yet it can hardly be characterised
as a positive one. Its hero, the Russian socialist exile Alexander
Herzen, has long figured in liberal discourse as a critic of utopias
and historical teleologies, and Stoppard merely follows in the footsteps
of Isaiah Berlin in creating a character defined by his rejection
of all forms of political utopianism. How historically accurate
is this portrait? The first part of my paper will argue that Stoppard's
selective use of sources purposefully underplays the constructive
and utopian aspects of Herzen's thought, particularly his
preoccupation with village communes – an interest which links
him with later anarchist and libertarian socialist writers like
Kropotkin and William Morris. But how can one account for this one-sided
representation? I will examine the nature of Stoppardian drama --
especially in contrast with the output of more politically-committed
contemporaries like David Hare -- and place his work in the broader
context of British theatre history. Ultimately, I argue, The Coast
of Utopia may serve as an illustration of the plight of the post-Cold
War liberal intelligentsia: too disillusioned (or too post-modern)
to offer solutions but still unable to put the ghosts of its socialist
past to rest.
Keywords: Tom Stoppard, Alexander Herzen, Intelligentsia
Fátima Vieira
Universidade do Porto
Vieira.mfatima@gmail.com
'Proles and animals are free': spaces of
control in George Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four
Spatiality Studies are founded on the idea set forth by Michel Foucault
in the 1970's that the understanding of our world cannot be
constructed from an exclusively historicist point of view. Defining
our epoch as the epoch of space, Foucault set the ground for a cultural
approach (developed at the time by Henri Lefebvre and, more recently,
by Edward Soja, Kathleen Kirby e Doreen Massey) that suggests that
the diachronic perspective of the historian should be complemented
by a synchronic perspective, shaped by the conceptual tools defined
by Post-modern Geography. Critics such as Fredric Jameson, David
Harvey and Louis Marin have evinced the way Utopian Studies can
benefit from a spatial analysis. Based on their theories, I will
put forward the idea that a thorough study of George Orwell's
dystopia, Nineteen Eighty-Four, must include the analysis of its
temporal meaning (i.e., the idea of a miserable future and the resulting
valorisation of the present), but also of its spatial dimension.
Keywords: Spatiality Studies, Literature, Dystopia
Dr. Robin Wilson
The Bartlett School of Architecture, U.C.L.
robin@interval.fsnet.co.uk
Now, this square is beautiful: the utopic document of
Lacaton & Vassal
This paper will introduce my research into the role of hidden or
repressed utopian expression in the architectural media. I will
argue that which Fredric Jameson terms the 'utopian impulse'
of cultural production has an important and often unconscious influence
within architectural journals, in their manner of textual and photographic
portrayal of buildings. I will clarify how Jameson and Louis Marin
understand utopian expression to have the capacity to produce a
critique of the ideology of which it is a part, and then will explain
how I understand this critical capacity might surface in architectural
journals to produce a critique of the architectural profession and
its methods of media dissemination.
I will discuss as a case study an article that appeared in a recent
edition of the Spanish architectural journal 2G, a monograph on
the French architects Lacaton & Vassal. Written by the architects
themselves (although not accredited), the article recounts the architects'
response to a brief from the Bordeaux city council to 'embellish'
a residential square near the St. Jean station. They decided to
do nothing, for the square 'was already beautiful'.
The design report thus becomes a eulogistic portrait of the square,
proclaiming its 'existing conditions of life'. I will
reveal how the rhetorical style of the article in its description
of the square shares certain traits with utopian works as analysed
by Marin, particularly in its use of person and tense. I will then
explain how the article introduces a covert critique of architectural
journalism's obsession with design objects.
Keywords: utopic critique, architectural media
Juan Miguel Zarandona
Universidad de Valladolid
zarandon@lia.uva.es
The linguistics and terminology of an early 20th-century
religious Dystopia, The Lord of the World (1907), by R.H. Benson,
and of its translations into Spanish, El amo del mundo (1909) and
Señor del mundo (2006).
Robert Hugh Benson (1871-1914), who was first ordained in the Church
of England but later converted to Catholicism in the wake of such
leading figures as Cardinal John Newman, also produced a huge amount
of fiction literature, which, nowadays, is not as well known as
it deserves. Especially remarkable were his apocalyptic anti-Utopian
novel, 'The Lord of the World' (1907), and his alternative Utopian
proposal, 'The Dawn of All', published a few years later, in 1911.
Both works are not only passionately propagandistic in favour of
his newly-found Catholic beliefs, but two surprising forerunners
of the main 20th century Dystopian anti-Utopian works to come, as
those by Huxley or Orwell. In other words, Benson emphasized and
foresaw the prospect of a global human society without God, and
by doing so produced some leading key works in the contemporary
history of Utopian fiction. Besides, 'The Lord of the World' was
translated into Spanish only two years later than the date of it
original publication in English, i.e. in 1909. Father Juan Mateos
was responsible for this early, only and forgotten Spanish rendering
of the novel, which he entitled: 'El amo del mundo'. There is no
doubt that this Spanish priest was highly seduced by its strong
religious contents, by its enthusiastic and energetic approach to
these subject matters, and for the novelty of the genre for Catholic
apologetic purposes. Something very similar happened with its new
translation of 2006. Consequently, this paper of mine, on the one
hand, will take advantage of the fact that we are celebrating the
first centennial of its first publication in 1907, and of its translation
into Spanish in 1909, in order to vindicate this writer and his
peculiar Dystopian, futuristic visions. On the other hand, it will
also focus its attention in how this pioneer Dystopian and science-fiction
novel treats linguistics and terminology issues, which always play
an important role in this kind of literature. And also, it will
focus on how the translators imported such typical jargon and phrases
in a language with a very short tradition in these genres that were
to become so popular a few years later.
Keywords: Dystopian, religion, end of the world, apocalyptic
Federico Zuolo
University of Pavia, Italy
federicozuolo@yahoo.it
Towards a Formal Definition of Utopia
In this paper I try to find out a non-commonsensical definition
of utopia through its formal features. I begin with the case of
Plato: the Laws, generally known as the 'realist' turn
after the Republic, is nevertheless a utopian theory. If in the
Laws we find both a 'realistic' and a 'utopian'
theory, then the concept of utopia needs a better definition. This
paper has two parts. In the first one, I criticize both commonsensical
and Mannheim's conceptions of utopia. The former conception
of utopia, based on the idea of unfeasibility, results too dependent
on controversial factual assumptions; while the latter is not able
to make clear the difference between utopia and mere normative theory.
In the second part of the paper, I characterize my conception pointing
at seven formal features that a theory should possess for being
considered utopian. Some of these features distinguish utopian theory
from ideal theory. While ideal theory provides only the normative
principles, utopian theory imagines the ideal state, as if it were
realized, in its concrete details. Moreover, an ideal society is
independent of history, while a utopian society wants to cancel
the temporal dimension. The features I outline in the list are not
new in the studies on utopia, nevertheless I try to define utopia
only by its formal features, without its content or scope, succeeding
in this way to distinguish utopia from a simple normative theory.
Finally, my aim is to show that this distinction has both a historiographical
and a theoretical interest.
Keywords: Definition of Utopia, Ideal, Mannheim
|